Arrival windows for HVAC and plumbing: 1, 2 or 4 hours?
Published by Relay. We make field service software, so we are one of the options in this space. Details about other products come from their own pricing pages and help documentation, checked November 5, 2026.
The usual promises are a two-hour arrival window or a morning or afternoon block of about four hours. A shorter window is a better promise, but it costs calls. In the example below, keeping two-hour windows through a bad day costs each technician one call a day compared with three- or four-hour windows, and one-hour windows cost two. Start with four-hour windows, keep the first call of the day tight, and give a day instead of a window when the day's route doesn't exist yet.
What shops promise today
Software sets the menu. Jobber's arrival window setting runs from 15 minutes to 4 hours, with no window by default, and the window can start at the scheduled time or be centered on it: a two-hour window for a 9 AM visit reads 8 to 10 AM. Jobber added arrival windows in March 2023, and they appear in booking confirmations and visit reminders. ServiceTitan has you set up preset windows, which may overlap; with its Capacity Planning turned on, every booked job needs one.
The case against short windows is not new. Writing in ACHR News in 2017, Nexstar coach Tom Merriott pointed to hard-to-reach equipment and technicians who take time to sell, and wrote that customers who want to talk or want other things checked "make hitting two-hour time windows consistently throughout the day challenging." His advice for shops that keep windows: if you're rescheduling two or three afternoon calls a day, book more in the middle of the day and fewer in the last slot, and track what happens to your afternoon calls.
What a shorter window costs in calls
Example: Sam works 8 to 5 with a half-hour lunch, which leaves 510 minutes for calls. Each call is planned at an hour on site with a 30-minute drive to the next, so six calls fit: arrivals at 8:00, 9:30 and 11:00, lunch at noon, then 1:00, 2:30 and 4:00, done at 5. Each customer's window is centered on Sam's planned arrival.
Now a bad day. Call 2 runs an hour over and the drive to call 3 takes 15 minutes more than planned. Sam reaches call 3 at 12:15 instead of 11:00, 75 minutes late, and every later call is 75 minutes late too.
| Window | Customer was told | At 12:15 |
|---|---|---|
| 1 hour | 10:30 to 11:30 | Missed by 45 minutes |
| 2 hours | 10:00 to 12:00 | Missed by 15 minutes |
| 3 hours | 9:30 to 12:30 | Kept, 15 minutes to spare |
| 4 hours | 9:00 to 1:00 | Kept, 45 minutes to spare |
A centered window absorbs half its length in delay: 30 minutes for a one-hour window, 60 for two hours, 90 for three and 120 for four. To keep two-hour promises through a 75-minute delay, Sam needs 15 minutes of slack before the next call. You don't know which call will run long, so the slack goes after every call. For one-hour windows it's 45 minutes after every call.
| Window | Slack after each call | Calls a day | Minutes used |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3 or 4 hours | None | 6 | 60 + 5 × 90 = 510 |
| 2 hours | 15 minutes | 5 | 60 + 4 × 105 = 480 |
| 1 hour | 45 minutes | 4 | 60 + 3 × 135 = 465 |
Sized for that bad day, two-hour windows cost Sam one call a day against three- or four-hour windows, about 250 calls a year over 50 five-day weeks. One-hour windows cost two. If you don't build the slack in, the cost arrives as phone calls to customers you're about to miss.
So size the window for the delay you want to absorb without calling anyone. If your day rarely falls more than an hour behind, two-hour windows are enough. A four-hour window also leaves room to add work. Put a new one-hour call between calls 2 and 3 on a good day and Sam reaches call 3 at 12:30: inside a 9-to-1 window, outside a 10-to-12 one.
Keeping the window once it's promised
Give the first call the tightest promise. Nothing earlier in the day can make Sam late for call 1, only the morning start. That's the one call where a set time or a one-hour window holds even if the rest of the day uses four hours. Put customers who have to leave for work there, and start the window when you open: a centered two-hour window around an 8 AM arrival would say 7 to 9, so say 8 to 10.
Put slack where delay piles up. Delay carries forward, so the last calls of the day carry the most risk, which is why Merriott's advice moves bookings out of the last slot. If you add slack, one gap after lunch covers every afternoon customer: on Sam's bad day, a 30-minute gap after lunch brings every afternoon call back to 45 minutes late, inside a two-hour window.
Text before the window is missed, not after. On Sam's bad day, the call 3 customer can hear at 10:30, when call 2 should have finished, instead of calling you at noon when the window closes. Give a new time you can keep and offer another day if they can't wait. Four customers are late that day; moving one afternoon call to another technician takes it off Sam's day and can bring every call after it back inside its window. Our free customer text templates include a running-late text.
When to give a day instead of a window
A window is only as good as the route behind it. Promise the day, and send the window later, when:
- The day's route doesn't exist yet. A window promised two weeks out pins a stop in a route you haven't built. Confirm the window the day before.
- Emergencies keep landing. In the first hot week of summer the route changes every hour. "Today" plus a text when the technician is on the way is a promise you can keep; Merriott goes further and argues for moving away from windows altogether.
- Nobody needs to be home. A vacant house, a lockbox, an outdoor unit or a business that's open all day doesn't need a window, and leaving it flexible gives the rest of the route room.
A day promise still needs a heads-up. Text when the technician leaves for the job, so the customer isn't waiting all day without news.
Arrival windows in Relay
Relay has one arrival window length for online booking and appointment confirmations: 2, 3 or 4 hours, set in Settings > Dispatch, with 4 recommended. The window is centered on the scheduled time: with 4-hour windows a 10 AM visit reads 8 AM to 12 PM, and with 2-hour windows a 1 PM visit reads 12 to 2. Near opening or closing the whole window shifts inside your hours, so with 2-hour windows an 8 AM first visit reads 8 to 10, not 7 to 9. There's no separate, shorter window for the first call of the day.
The day-before confirmation and the morning-of reminder name that window. Once a customer has been told a window, it stands: the visit can move within it without another text, and changing your window length later doesn't rewrite it. Moving the visit outside the window gives it a new window and a new confirmation.
For online booking and Relay's voice and text agents, you choose whether customers get a window. With "Offer confirmed arrival windows" on, Relay checks each window against current jobs, qualified technicians, shifts and drive time before offering it, and checks the chosen one again at confirmation. The recommended setting, "Day only until the route is built", lets customers reserve the day and gives new bookings a window once that day's route is built. A customer who has to leave by a set time gets one shorter window that fits, at least an hour long: with an 8 AM opening and 3-hour windows, a customer who leaves for work at 10 is offered 8 to 10. When Relay builds or reshuffles a day, it can move a visit anywhere inside the window the customer chose, never outside it, and if it can't keep every promise it changes nothing.
When a technician is running late, choose Running late on the job in the Schedule and enter the delay. Relay shows how the later visits shift and, when the delay runs into overtime, suggests moving a later visit to another technician. After you confirm, it opens an editable text for the customers whose appointments moved, and you choose who gets it. By default, when the technician taps On my way, the customer gets a text with a link to their appointment page. Relay is $99 a month for 1–2 technicians or $199 for 3–9. See the scheduling page for how placement works.
Bottom line
Start with four-hour windows, or morning and afternoon, and give the first call of the day a set time or a one-hour window. Move to two-hour windows if your day rarely falls more than an hour behind, or if you'll give up about a call per technician per day for the slack. One-hour windows belong on the first call, not the whole day.
Give a day instead of a window when the route isn't built yet, on days when emergencies keep landing, and for customers who don't need to be home. Whatever you promise, text before the window is missed. For how booking software should check drive time before it promises a window, see our technician scheduling software guide.