Relay
Pricing
Get started
Pricing
Get started
Guides

Speed to lead: responding to Angi, Thumbtack and Google LSA leads

Published by Relay. We make field service software, so we are one of the options in this space. Details about other products come from their own pricing pages and help documentation, checked November 5, 2026.

Marketplace leads are shared, and every platform rewards a fast reply. Angi matches each request with up to five pros and charges you whether or not you respond. Thumbtack ranks pros partly on how fast they reply and tracks the share of leads they answer within an hour. Google ranks Local Services Ads partly on responsiveness and charges you for a call you miss during business hours if the caller waits more than 20 seconds. So reply within five minutes with one question and a time you can come, decline what you can't do right away, and judge each source by what you pay per booked job, not per lead.

In this guide

  1. How Angi, Thumbtack and Google treat response time
  2. Credits and refunds for bad leads
  3. What the lead response study measured
  4. What to send in the first five minutes
  5. Qualify the job, then offer two times
  6. Cost per booked job by source
  7. When a marketplace isn't worth it
  8. Answering new leads with Relay
  9. Bottom line

How Angi, Thumbtack and Google treat response time

From each platform's help center, read November 5, 2026.
PlatformWho else gets the customerWhen you payHow response speed counts
AngiNo more than five pros per request.When you and the homeowner both show interest. You're charged whether or not you open or respond to the lead.Angi tells pros to follow up quickly. A credit request needs a call attempt within 24 hours.
ThumbtackThe customer picks whom to contact. A lead labeled Only picked you hasn't contacted another pro yet.Automatically, at the lead price you set, when a customer whose job matches your preferences reaches out to you.Response speed is a ranking factor. Its three best matches section needs an average reply time of four hours or less.
Google Local Services AdsAds are ranked in an auction. A message lead's price depends partly on whether the customer contacted other advertisers.For each valid lead, including a call you miss during business hours if the caller stays on the line more than 20 seconds.Responsiveness and average response time count toward ad ranking. Missed calls can count against you.

Angi. Each lead includes the homeowner's name, location, project details and contact information. You choose how Angi tells you about a new one: app push notification, text message, email or phone call. Pick the one you'll notice on a job, because the charge is already made. Source: Angi's Opportunities and leads FAQ.

Thumbtack. Your response rate is the share of leads you answer within an hour, counted between 8 am and 8 pm your time, so a lead that arrives at 10 pm has until 9 am. Its Gold and Platinum Pro Rewards tiers need 65% and 75%. Declining with Can't do it still counts as acting on the lead. Leads come with a Thumbtack number that carries calls and texts between you and the customer. A text from a number you haven't registered in your Thumbtack account waits until someone enters your seven-digit access code, so register every number you or your software text from. Sources: rank in search results, Pro Rewards, responding to leads, Thumbtack numbers.

Google Local Services Ads. Calls come through a Google forwarding number to your business phone. A message lead shares the customer's name, ZIP code, job details and phone number, and Google emails you about it (Local Services accounts can also get a text). Once you've had two message leads in 90 days, your ad can show your estimated reply time, from a few minutes to one day, worked out over your business hours with recent leads weighted more. Google is moving these ads into Google Ads as Performance Max campaigns with pay-per-lead goals. The first phase began in August 2026 for select US home service advertisers, including HVAC and plumbing; service-area businesses without a storefront follow in late 2026. After the move, the lead inbox is the Leads page in Google Ads, and old Local Services reports don't carry over; Google says to screenshot any you need before you move. Sources: ad rankings, managing leads, the move to Google Ads.

Credits and refunds for bad leads

  • Angi may credit a lead with a disconnected or wrong phone number, a job outside your ZIP codes, a job outside your services, a duplicate within 45 days, or a charge while your leads were paused. The lead must be under 45 days old, you should have tried to call within 24 hours, and annual subscriptions get no credits. Credits go toward future leads and expire after six months (Angi lead credits).
  • Thumbtack refunds a lead automatically when the customer replies to no pro within 72 hours, as long as you replied within four business hours (8 am to 8 pm) through Thumbtack's messenger or the Thumbtack number, and didn't share your own phone or email before the customer's first reply. Other cases, such as an invalid phone number, a job that changed significantly or a duplicate, are reviewed if you ask within 45 days. Refunds go to your Thumbtack balance by default (Fair Shot refunds, refund policy).
  • Google doesn't charge for leads its systems judge invalid, such as spam or duplicate contacts, and keeps reassessing charged leads for 30 days, crediting low-quality ones automatically. You can rate each lead in a feedback survey. Google no longer credits leads for a job type or area you don't serve, so keep your service areas and job types accurate (how leads work, automated lead credits).

Angi and Thumbtack both say outright that losing the customer to another pro isn't grounds for a credit. Angi lists The homeowner hired another pro before you reached them among the cases its lead prices already account for.

What the lead response study measured

The most quoted numbers on response time come from a 2007 study by InsideSales.com, a seller of lead response software, and James Oldroyd, then a faculty fellow at MIT. It was presented at a business-to-business marketing summit and used three years of data from six companies that phoned people who had filled in a web form: over 15,000 leads and over 100,000 call attempts. It measured whether a call reached the person and whether the lead qualified, which for some companies meant setting an appointment. It didn't measure sales.

Its findings: the odds of reaching a lead fell more than 10 times within the first hour. Between a call at 5 minutes and one at 30 minutes, the odds of reaching the lead dropped 100 times and the odds of qualifying it dropped 21 times. Source: a 2008 copy of the study summary.

The six companies aren't named, and the callers were sales reps working web leads, so treat the numbers as direction, not a forecast for your shop. The marketplaces' own rules point the same way: Thumbtack counts replies within an hour, and Angi won't credit a lead whose homeowner hired another pro before you reached them.

What to send in the first five minutes

The first reply has three jobs: show that a real business answered, ask the one question that decides whether you can take the job, and give the customer a next step. Leave out the price list and the request to call you back.

  • When you can offer a time: Hi Dana, it's Sam at Oak Street Heating. Sorry the furnace quit. Is it running and blowing cold, or not coming on at all? We can be there today between 2 and 4 pm.
  • When you need details first: Hi Luis, Oak Street Plumbing here. Is the water heater leaking right now, and is it gas or electric? Once I know, I'll send you two times.
  • After a missed call from your ad: call back first. If there's no answer, text: Hi, it's Oak Street Plumbing returning your call. What's going on, and what's the address?
  • When it isn't your kind of job: decline straight away, with Can't do it on Thumbtack or Decline in Google's lead inbox. Thumbtack counts it toward your response time, and the customer can move on.

On Thumbtack, send the first reply in its app or to the Thumbtack number. Giving your own number or email before the customer answers costs you the Fair Shot refund. Set notifications so a new lead interrupts you: Thumbtack's pro app sends push notifications, Google emails you, and Angi can call you. For the texts that come after booking (the confirmation, the reminder, on my way) use our free customer text templates.

Qualify the job, then offer two times

Ask only what changes whether you take the job, who goes, or how long it takes: what's wrong and since when, the equipment or fixture, the address with ZIP code, and when someone can be home. For a rental, ask who approves the work. If the customer mentions a gas smell, booking waits: tell them to leave the building and call the gas utility. Our after-hours call script covers the other emergencies.

Then offer two specific times rather than asking when suits them. A choice of two gets a one-word answer. Offer only times a tech can make once you count the drive from the job before; our technician scheduling guide has a two-technician example. Say what the visit costs before you book: if you charge a diagnostic fee, our service call fee guide covers how to word it. Confirm the day and arrival window in writing once it's on the schedule.

Cost per booked job by source

Cost per lead tells you what a marketplace charges. Cost per booked job tells you what a customer costs: spend for the month divided by the jobs that made it onto your schedule. Here is a made-up month for a two-technician shop. The numbers aren't prices from any platform.

Example only. First-visit gross profit is $250: a $425 average first ticket minus $175 in parts and the tech's time.
This monthSource ASource BSource C
Spend this month$1,200$750$1,300
Leads302520
Cost per lead$40$30$65
Booked jobs459
Booking rate13.3%20%45%
Cost per booked job$300$150$144.44
First-visit gross profit left after the lead-$50$100$105.56

Source B has the cheapest leads, but Source C is cheapest per booked job ($1,300 ÷ 9 = $144.44) because it books 45% of its leads. Source A loses $50 on every first visit ($250 − $300).

Your reply time feeds straight into this number. If faster replies took Source A from 4 bookings to 6 on the same 30 leads, its cost per booked job would fall to $200 ($1,200 ÷ 6) and each first visit would clear $50. With those 6 bookings, if 3 of its leads were outside your area and credited at $40 each, spend falls to $1,080 and the cost per booked job to $180.

To get the inputs: Thumbtack's Performance tab downloads up to 12 months of lead details as a CSV, and the Leads page in Google Ads shows each lead's charge status and can be downloaded. Count a lead as booked only when the job is on the schedule, and mark the source on every job so you can add up the revenue later.

When a marketplace isn't worth it

A source pays when its cost per booked job stays below your gross profit on the first visit, plus any repeat work you've actually seen from its customers. Give it two or three months of fast replies before you judge it, because a slow month tells you about your response time, not the source.

  • Fix targeting before you quit. If many leads are outside your area or your services, tighten your services and service area in Angi, your job preferences in Thumbtack, or your service areas and job types in Google. Google no longer credits those leads, and Angi credits them only if you ask.
  • Turn leads off when you can't answer. Angi charges whether or not you respond, so pause automatic leads or switch to short-term coverage during a busy week. Thumbtack lets you hide your business, and Google lets you pause your ad or run it on a schedule.
  • Drop it if the cost per booked job stays above your first-visit gross profit after you've fixed speed and targeting.

A marketplace also isn't worth it if nobody can reply within the hour during the day. A one-technician shop on a four-hour job can't reply within the hour unless something answers for it, and a lead you pay for and don't answer is the most expensive kind.

Answering new leads with Relay

Relay texts a new lead as soon as it arrives, at any hour. It takes leads from website forms and from the Generic Webhook address under Settings > Lead Capture, which Zapier, Make, n8n, a website form tool or a lead vendor can post to. For calls, with Relay Phone on, your team's phones ring during business hours for the time you set (15 seconds by default), then the AI receptionist answers. A Google Local Services call forwards to your business number, so if that number rings through Relay, a caller nobody picks up reaches the receptionist rather than voicemail.

In the text conversation, the AI matches the request to one of your services and asks one question when it matters, such as repair or replace. It checks the address against your service area, asking for the ZIP code if it's missing, offers one or two times from your schedule, and when the customer accepts, checks that time again and books the job. It usually books a day; on a day whose route is already built, it can offer an arrival window if you offer confirmed arrival windows. If the lead goes quiet, Relay follows up on days 1, 3 and 7 by default. Follow-ups go out only between 8 AM and 8 PM your time, and any reply ends the sequence.

A request for a person, a billing dispute, no available times or a question the AI can't answer comes to you as a Needs you item with a push notification. Reply yourself and Relay stops texting that customer. Messages inside Thumbtack, Angi and Google's lead inbox stay in those apps, so answer them there. Relay is $99 a month for 1–2 technicians or $199 for 3–9 with unlimited office users; the AI receptionist includes 100 minutes, then $0.30 a minute.

Bottom line

If you can reply within five minutes during working hours, marketplace leads can pay. Turn on the notifications you'll actually see, reply with one question and a time, decline what you can't do, and work out cost per booked job for every source each month. Keep the sources that stay under your first-visit gross profit, fix targeting on the ones that don't, and drop what's still over after two or three months.

If you're on jobs most of the day and leads wait until evening, stop paying for leads you can't answer, or put something in front of them that replies and books within minutes: a person, or an AI that offers real times. Our missed-call text back guide covers booking by text, and our AI receptionist cost guide covers what call answering costs.

See how Relay answers and books new leads

Free tools: Missed-call cost calculator and Customer text templates.

Book a demo

All guides

Product

  • All features
  • AI Front Office
  • Business Phone
  • Website
  • Booking
  • Pipelines
  • Scheduling & dispatch
  • Mobile App
  • Pricebook
  • Inventory
  • Time tracking & timesheets
  • Estimates & proposals
  • Invoicing & payments
  • Customer management
  • Maintenance plans
  • Review requests
  • Customer campaigns
  • Reports & profitability

Compare

  • Relay vs Housecall Pro
  • Relay vs Jobber
  • Relay vs ServiceTitan
  • Relay vs Workiz
  • Relay vs FieldPulse

Industries

  • HVAC
  • Plumbing
  • Electrical
  • Garage door
  • Appliance repair

Legal

  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • SMS Policy
  • Account Deletion

Company

  • About
  • Guides
  • Free tools
  • Help center
  • Contact
  • Support
© 2026 Relay Ops, Inc.